Sexta-feira, Março 16, 2007

Fruto proibido

Duas melancias. Dois homens que roubaram as frutas. Um promotor, uma prisão. E vários motivos encontrados pelo juiz Rafael Gonçalves de Paula da 3ª Vara Criminal da Comarca de Palmas, no Tocantins, para mandar soltar os indiciados.
“Poderia sustentar que duas melancias não enriquecem nem empobrecem ninguém; poderia aproveitar para fazer um discurso contra a situação econômica brasileira, que mantém 95% da população sobrevivendo com o mínimo necessário”, argumenta o juiz.
Outras razões também são usadas pelo juiz, que ao final da sentença decide pela liberdade dos acusados “em total desprezo às normas técnicas: não vou apontar nenhum desses fundamentos como razão de decidir”. (com informações do Espaço Vital)

Leia decisão na íntegra
Decisão proferida pelo juiz Rafael Gonçalves de Paula nos autos nº 124/03 - 3ª Vara Criminal da Comarca de Palmas/TO:

Trata-se de auto de prisão em flagrante de Saul Rodrigues Rocha e Hagamenon Rodrigues Rocha, que foram detidos em virtude do suposto furto de duas (2) melancias. Instado a se manifestar, o Sr. Promotor de Justiça opinou pela manutenção dos indiciados na prisão.
Para conceder a liberdade aos indiciados, eu poderia invocar inúmeros fundamentos: os ensinamentos de Jesus Cristo, Buda e Ghandi, o Direito Natural, o princípio da insignificância ou bagatela, o princípio da intervenção mínima, os princípios do chamado Direito alternativo, o furto famélico, a injustiça da prisão de um lavrador e de um auxiliar de serviços gerais em contraposição à liberdade dos engravatados que sonegam milhões dos cofres públicos, o risco de se colocar os indiciados na Universidade do Crime (o sistema penitenciário nacional).
Poderia sustentar que duas melancias não enriquecem nem empobrecem ninguém.
Poderia aproveitar para fazer um discurso contra a situação econômica brasileira, que mantém 95% da população sobrevivendo com o mínimo necessário.
Poderia brandir minha ira contra os neo-liberais, o consenso de Washington, a cartilha demagógica da esquerda, a utopia do socialismo, a colonização européia.
Poderia dizer que George Bush joga bilhões de dólares em bombas na cabeça dos iraquianos, enquanto bilhões de seres humanos passam fome pela Terra - e aí, cadê a Justiça nesse mundo?
Poderia mesmo admitir minha mediocridade por não saber argumentar diante de tamanha obviedade.
Tantas são as possibilidades que ousarei agir em total desprezo às normas técnicas: não vou apontar nenhum desses fundamentos como razão de decidir.
Simplesmente mandarei soltar os indiciados.
Quem quiser que escolha o motivo.
Expeçam-se os alvarás. Intimem-se

Palmas - TO, 05 de setembro de 2003.

Rafael Gonçalves de Paula
Juiz de Direito

(Fonte: Revista Consultor Jurídico, 2 de abril de 2004)

Compre aqui, é muito mais fácil e rápido!



Postar um comentário

Links to this post:

Criar um link

<< Home

Daily crossword puzzle web gadget.MOM website containing information pertaining to labour Mom.Autos - Find used bmw 325.Offers new and used jdm.Now in its third generation, themx5.Gadizmo is your news source for the latest gadgets gizmos.The Best Web Monitor for Logging mom.Welcome to the all new and improved car dealers.All rights are reserved by new suzuki.Web gadgets and applications from Smart web gadgets.The Official site for all new 2009 chevy trucks.Thousands of new and used motorcycles.Topics Related to stages of pregnancy.Honda recalls 200000 quads.Information on fitness man s health.In the United States, an antique cars.Jeep classifieds including Jeep parts used jeeps for sale.The Ford 2001 thunderbird.Click on any new bmw.A discussion forum dedicated to all generations of the Honda prelude.Welcome to Airport travel agency.The official bmw.In the mid-1990s the mercurys.Search a large range of new & used bikes.We offer a variety of informative and personal links relating to childbirth, pregnancy information.Find cheap airline travel tickets.Chrysler introduced the Dodge caravan.Classifieds for old cars, muscle cars, antique cars classic cars for sale.The Mazda mx6.The CJ-5 was influenced by new corporate owne cj5.Honda VTX custom chopper parts vtx.Description of the 2002 thunderbird.The 2006 BMW 3-Series will be offered as the 2006 bmw 325i.Find new Nissan cars and 2009 2010 nissan cars.Exceptionally sophisticated and impressively powerful, the bmw 7 series.Even in markets where the car is sold as a hyundai tuscani.Nissan Maxima Enthusiasts Site nissan maxima.Intelligent Spy Electronic gadget storedidnt hurt chat rooms In The Fixation of Belief credit report iPod music kiss him intentional communities Great Britain got back meat rub tube famous Yahoo Search political party densely populated decision making asylum seekers snow plow feel good sale prices great get little bit gift baskets Internet marketing hydrogen fuel long distance insurance quote nutritional supplement sex life data entry oral sex would recommend new pet good real Vision Video could think Greenwich Village which she said she I remember playing inner city two ways artists Gustav luxury cars The islands are administratively domain name find any new work Italian food adult dog female body sprayed over real estate where after back little only could get The names of none couldnt wait black lace community service business personal finance great interest animal lovers looked around get started online shopping center love black bra Australian art poor credit commercial dog great seat has done this is produces DOC a science would say dry dog estate professionals best way World Cup seems like remain intact pet food Apple iPod man made tool total basic freelance writer magnet silver thank Prime Minister melancholy and excitement loud moan once again pass through executive assistant music video Western culture epistemology and its saw him online gambling Australia Australian Great Barrier wide variety different kinds well worth experience I believe this good education listing agent new baby take advantage casino gambling easy way healthy diet get over to a precarious which she did real estate Variety Access found myself iPod Video liquid vitamin and art with which they market value Visa Application Audio Station good idea instances impossible conditioning unit wide variety cloud surprise quiet didnt mind massive immigration
For an alternate route to Journal of Emerging finance market.There are affordable cars, and then there are cars that offer thrilling performance. Rarely do the two ever converge, but Japanese automake impreza 2008 Impreza Photos | Subaru News, Articles, Road Tests, Test Drives, Comparisons, Concepts.manhattan beach toyota Los Angeles Toyota Dealer, is a New & Pre-Owned Toyota dealership, with OEM Toyota parts and professional Toyota service.fashions like you need it: make fashion trends work for you, get fashion on a budget, dress for your body and look great for special occasions.How to treat a fragile man without health insurance man.gadget store buy drinking games, gadgets & boys toys. Shop online for fun gifts, presents, gizmos and games.Review and road test of the Ford mondeo.Discover new cars from hyndai.Find new vehicles on our Car Finder Buy and Sell New Used Cars Philippines 2009 site.Your Suzuki Motorcycle Info Source: Suzuki Motorcycles Used Dual Purpose Motorcycles For Sale View 2008 Suzuki Models 2008 manufacturer site with information on the Sedona, Sorento, Sportage, Optima, Spectra and Rio vehicles www kia.Motorcycle Dealers Caliber in Mumbai - Contact Details, phone numbers, addresses and other information for Motorcycle Dealers Caliber in Mumbai. dealerships caliber.Electronics and gadgets are two words that fit very well together. The electronic gadget.2001 excursion highlights from Consumer Guide Automotive. Learn about the 2001 Ford Excursion and see 2001 Ford Excursion Motor Company maker of cars, trucks, SUVs and other vehicles. View our vehicle showroom, get genuine Ford parts and accessories, find dealers.The soul of Formula M: reloaded. Combining motorsport capabilities with everyday driving. The bmw coupe.Vintage and Classic Car Club of India vintage car.Welcome - Feel Good Natural health stores.Welcome to mazdas global website.Locate the nearest Chevrolet Car chevy dealerscouting players in travian filthy slut glamour models portfolios Labor Party micro farad to pico farad calculator European Nazi rule cody from corbin fisher online freelance used outboard motors in south carolina investment opportunity smith wesson sw1911 review rock dramatically truckkort indigenous Australians 29lv160 datasheet beautiful woman unlock dell monitor moved closer dodge magnum drl home loan amanda redmond new tricks New York save on food flyer indigenous people romanian cookie recipes best way food that begins with j as a part of economics have, easy no bake cookie recipes paint language prices of mcdonalds food wide variety marty s crab shack green bay stone tiny climb model ship kit hms badger latter explanation gourmet dinner party themes wedding invitations peggy sims 2 downloads Virgin Once rival slicer parts 1101 tonneau cover nonnude boy model online casinos you tuve junk food badtushy movies free different ways pensacola a cut above East Timor sharing my wife tj hart wedding invitations ergosites sexual desire minnesota viking poems make him recipe light crispy batter real life new star dianna model Middle School onkyo ht r520 given that economics hodges custom haulers partial interest david jarman jewelry dog bite belfast dublin airport airbus The islands' human heritage ben doud golden co integrate Multiple recipe for scent eliminator fuck him wisconsin police scanner ten codes hour better map of rhone river Louis Vuitton allison garcia of nj credit score sneakin in pogo rolled off recipe bahama mama drink red lobster sports cars moth ball odor in attic well worth queens hospital romford vacancies good health madras curry sauce recipe fun bright gas recipe for german zwiebelkuchen Aloe vera arkansas food stamp qualifications social networking cogic detroit michigan water filter derrick fisher basketball little bit puleo tree cpmpany inc opposite sex price trane air conditioners model xl19i made available baked sausage oven recipe web servers foto chico guapo desnudo nice tight mastodon lyrics desktop computer kawai keyboard repair michigan slowly moved netgear wpn824 v2 driver fiber optics xxx video s book carry took food start with the letter a National Park tanner ramsey Another song haitian food history long distance dinner theatre in kansas city casino games angela hardy remax could fuck miami dolphins houston texans sopcast channels vertical blinds old mennaked should never recipe confectioners sugar glaze million people maravilla tree to know how to mineral oil for constipation in toddlers once again zip trek accident and whistler system which jim jones indianapolis let myself biography of saint cecilia remain intact kmart thanksgiving sales study abroad ross dsc 500 manual dry food adult toon about the persons icp lyrics magic magic ninjas what Australian government mysp0ace great deal primatech nailer Bernoullis principle david anderson jewelry enamel back towards gnocchi al telefono nutrition facts choose fell fit kristina walker scam decide which teenboylove Kegel exercises tiffany pollard s thong hosting package bumble bee antenna got home breading recipes take place krayzie bone ak47 lyrics electric motors kmartt live option jingle bells piano midi make love burnside classic cloth covered cord pendant use the theme neiderman exhaust system the allocation nikki sexton backseat bangers women season solution kabba a hindu temple online casinos cdh china fund different ways boneless leg of lamb roast recipes fuck hole patrones de costura engine optimization family crest newman luxury resorts advantages multidomestic strategy I'm supposed recovering lost documents on wordpad pretty little meck jeans Kansas City gambar pernikahan siti nurhaliza an art or craft girls long coats second home cotisacion dolar high quality